How has Twitter not permanently canceled JK Rowling yet?
In the information age, celebrities are thrust into the spotlight more than ever before. Interviews, article coverage, social media – if you want to know more about someone or not, you will. Some celebrities use it to their advantage, expanding their platform to inspire change.
But more often than not, the rapid spread of celebrity news serves to expose when they misstep. When celebrities dink up, the internet lights up and their reputation usually makes a swift plummet. However, some celebrities have such a huge platform that they can withstand the heat, coming through it with their fan base mostly intact.
Unfortunately, Harry Potter author JK Rowling is one of those toxic celebrities that just won’t stay down. It’s hard to keep track of everything she’s done wrong at this point but here’s a meager summary:
Rowling has insisted on inserting marginalized identities into her novels that weren’t there when they first came out. She has consistently supported transphobic tweets, tweeted her own transphobic positions, and is now publishing a transphobic book. (Not to mention, her newest additions to the Harry Potter universe in America demonstrate cultural theft & misrepresentation of Native American religion.)
At first, it was a little fuzzy – is JK Rowling really transphobic or is she just misjudging things? But at this point, JK Rowling has overwhelmingly proven herself to be a grade-A TERF (trans-exclusionary radical “feminist.) It’s appalling that Rowling hasn’t been booed off her Twitter stage yet. When will Twitter finally say enough is enough and turn its back on the offensive Harry Potter icon?
If JK Rowling hasn’t torn up Twitter enough with her transphobic meltdowns, she has now introduced her transphobic meltdown to her new book Troubled Blood. The fifth installment of her Cormoran Strike series, Troubled Blood has sold almost 65,00o copies despite the backlash against its transphobic content.
In this installment of her thriller series, JK Rowling introduces a serial killer who dresses in women’s clothing. A review by Telegraph labeled the murder suspect a “transvestite serial killer” and asked “what critics of Rowling’s stance on trans issues will make of a book whose moral seems to be: never trust a man in a dress.”
This controversy sparked the hashtag #RIPJKRowling on Twitter and users called for the novel to be burned. Bookshops around the world announced that they would stop selling her books after Rowling expressed the opinion that trans women who haven’t undergone hormone therapy or surgical transition shouldn’t be allowed into single-sex spaces.
Rowling’s only response to the controversy was to claim the book was loosely based on two real serial killers. Her instance to be unapologetic about the damage she does to the vulnerable trans community proves her voice shouldn’t be listened to.
JK Rowling made the decision to insert her transphobic opinions into a published book. Pining Harry Potter burn-outs who blindly eat up Rowling’s lackluster writing are supporting and engaging with her transphobic mission.
Sometimes a T-shirt just speaks to you…
(From https://t.co/hhOu3fO1rg, in case you know a witch who'd like one 😉) pic.twitter.com/T4E9OCMCMI
— J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) September 22, 2020
JK Rowling’s latest toxic Twitter post featured the author flaunting her new T-shirt purchase. The T-shirt reads “This witch doesn’t burn.” Her comment on the post says “Sometimes a T-shirt just speaks to you.” Rowling’s flashy buy is a likely response to the backlash against her.
Rowling also makes a point to call out the online store that she bought from: the wild womyn workshop. A simple search into this store reveals a plethora of transphobic merchandise. The UK-based online store includes a “Gender Critical” section where they sell pins that say “Transwomen are men”, “Woman is not a costume” and “F*ck your pronouns.”
In order to express her allyship with this awful TERF merchandise shop she told her followers not to support other stores and added the hashtag #supportwomenrunbusinesses.
Can’t this be the final straw already? Twitter needs to cut her off before she spouts even more hateful opinions or supports more toxic organizations.
The hate stings
Harry Potter fans everywhere are feeling betrayed by the author’s open transphobia. (Especially fans who are trans.) Those who grew up cherishing the series are now questioning who they’ve been looking up to, and if her creations can stand apart from her awful influence. Every oncoming JK Rowling offense is like rubbing salt in the wound.
Though it’s hard to give up on the Wizarding World of Harry Potter – especially with the new Harry Potter Legacy video game coming out – former fans are pushing for a JK Rowling boycott. If we can do anything to tear down the TERF, we can start by refusing to put any more money in her pocket.
We’re crossing our fingers that JK Rowling’s net worth will drop, and that her platform will burn along with it. Crushed fans can root for the scenario where her rags-to-riches tale transforms into a riches-to-rags tale.
For goodness sake Twitter, please open your eyes and cancel JK Rowling already. Strip the TERF of her platform before she does any more harm to the trans community. End the hate.
What are your thoughts on JK Rowling’s transphobia? Share your view in the comments section below.
JK Rowling is a heroine to the cause of women’s rights everywhere.September 24, 2020
You should be thanking her.
In fact, you probably will one day.
Once you stop drinking the Kool-Aid.
You may think it is fine for a non surgical transgender woman, with decades of testosterone all through their puberty to occupy a womans safe space, but it is hardly radical for someone to disagree.September 24, 2020
It seems like all the hate is coming from the author of this article. Talking about tearing people down, RIP-ing people, boycotting people. It is contrary to liberalism, if you disagree with someone’s point of view then put your points across, and debate with them. She isn’t calling for you to be torn down, or Trans people. She has a point of view, that differs from yours, she isn’t hurting people.
You won’t change her opinion by no platforming her, or those who agree with her. It is incredibly fascist to attempt to silence people whom you disagree with, and lazy. Also, it simply doesn’t work, by your own accounts her new book has sold many copies, and your giving it free publicity. People will buy it to see what all the fuss is about.
Lets stop this talk of bringing people down and have some open dialogue and debate.October 19, 2020
When has stating your opinion on a controversial issue deemed you toxic and evil? I’m so glad that there’s is more awareness about trans folks’ experiences and needs, but we can’t cancel out people who have a different view and might offend some.
Women have been protected in our society for many centuries, and with trans rights now a part of the conversation (which is great!) some women’s rights will have to be shifted to accommodate. It’s not easy and it will take time to work out. But if we can’t listen to each other then, we will never move forward supporting everyone.
Cancel culture will just hurt more people that it tries to protects.October 22, 2020
“Transphobia” sure gets tossed around lightly these days…
I still don’t understand what’s controversial about pointing out that biological sex is real, and has real world consequences for women. De-platforming and silencing women speaking about their rights and safety seems cruel, and yes, fascist. It validates the feelings of a small group of people, and achieves little else, except advancing the idea that felt gender identity trumps biological sex in sports, bathrooms, and prisons. Hint: it’s half the population will suffer because of this. It is such a step backwards. Horrendous.
By the way, de-platforming only happens when lobbyists finance it. It’s not a dedication to truth or human rights. It’s just about profit. I’m sorry you were subjected to an opinion which hurt your feelings in a tweet. I’m sorry someone wrote something into a book something which has happened in real life. If it helps, Rowling was sent death and rape threats over it.
Meanwhile, I’m sorry that no biological woman will ever stand on the Olympics podium again, or be assured her safety in a changing room.October 24, 2020
I’m surprised that the authors woke peers allow her/him/ze to identify as a druid. Surely that is cultural appopriation of some sort? Unless ofcourse she is infact an ancient Celt!January 5, 2021
lmao, this website…
Helping children and paying millions to charities, and oh noes..saying they’re proud to be a biological woman, or they feel you can’t change whether you have more XY/XX (because you know, science exists).
Why on earth would someone be banned at all for this? How about banning the LGB psycopaths who threaten her life or make vile tweets? How about banning Seth Rogan who threatened her life and again made many vile swearing tweets children will see? You people (pretending following science is remotely bad) have some messed up priorities.March 24, 2022