Trending News
Will Shannan and the other victims ever get the justice they so rightfully deserve? And does the cast of the biopic owe their trauma to their story?

Discover why the ‘Lost Girls’ cast blames Netflix for their trauma

Can you imagine the heartbreak of losing your child and facing a wall of unanswered questions? Netflix’s Lost Girls invites you on a harrowing journey, spotlighting one mother’s relentless pursuit for justice and a botched investigation, against the eerily peaceful backdrop of Gilgo Beach. 

What does the cast itself think of the impact of the movie? And more importantly, does the Lost Girls cast blame Netflix for the trauma they have been through? Let’s dive into the true thoughts of the cast and see what we can find!

New secrets

Unveiled in 2020, Lost Girls is a riveting portrayal of Mari Gilbert’s ceaseless quest for the truth surrounding her daughter, Shannan’s baffling disappearance. This complex narrative unfolds against the startling discovery of ten bodies concealed on a seemingly serene beach. 

Amy Ryan brilliantly embodies Mari, a mother constantly at loggerheads with then-Police Commissioner Richard Dormer, encapsulated by Gabriel Byrne. Dormer consistently brushes off Shannan’s disappearance as a result of her erratic behavior and ‘natural causes’, sparking suspicion about a cover-up.

Fast forward to 2022, and enter Rodney Harrison, Suffolk County’s new Police Commissioner, who pumps fresh life into the stagnant case. 

Assembling a unique special task force of local, state, and federal officers, he rekindles the hunt for the elusive serial killer. Harrison’s innovative approach yields results when fifty-nine-year-old Rex Heuermann is charged with three of the murders and suspected in a fourth. Yet, amidst this significant breakthrough, Shannan Gilbert’s fate remains shrouded in mystery.

The timeline

The twisted tale kicks off with a panicked 911 call from Shannan, a twenty-three-year-old escort, and her subsequent vanishing act. Mari, Shannan’s unwavering mother, rallies against Suffolk County authorities, uniting with other victims’ families in their shared quest for justice.

 Mari’s tenacity steers the police to Gilgo Beach, where they uncover the remains of Melisa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman, and Amber Lynn Costello, chillingly wrapped in burlap sacks. It takes a year before these tragic victims are identified, with some missing for three years prior to the gruesome discovery.

At the core of this horrifying saga are young women entangled in the sex work industry, advertising their services on Craigslist. This grim commonality suggests the killer’s first contact was likely made online. However, the victims seem to have met their untimely end at different times, adding another layer of complexity to the sinister case.

As the investigation trudges on, additional bodies surface along the same stretch of coastline, including a toddler and the skull of Jessica Taylor, a prostitute from New York City. Another victim found near Gilgo Beach is eventually identified as twenty-four-year-old Valerie Mack. In a chilling turn of events, Shannan Gilbert’s naked body is discovered in a neighboring marsh, with police maintaining her death bears no relation to the others.

In these tumultuous times, Mari steps up, rallying other grieving families and demanding action. They hold press conferences, relentlessly questioning Richard Dormer’s handling of the case, and the then Police Commissioner’s seeming negligence or corruption.

The Unanswered Questions

The initial investigation is riddled with inconsistencies and glaring errors, with officials even waffling over whether all the murders were the handiwork of a single suspect. 

As Suffolk police appeared disinterested in hunting down the killer, citing the victims’ occupation as a reason for their apathy, the case went cold. The families left behind grappled not only with the brutal loss but also the crushing frustration of a seemingly indifferent justice system.

In a tragic twist of fate, Mari was killed in 2016 by her schizophrenic daughter, Sarra, never witnessing justice for Shannan. The revelations in Lost Girls lay bare the chilling secrets of Gilgo Beach, while simultaneously posing critical questions about justice, and how society values individuals.

So, as the credits roll, we are left with one burning question: Will Shannan and the other victims ever get the justice they so rightfully deserve?

Share via:
No Comments

Leave a Comment